Evangelism That Meets Students Where They Are
Listen to the conversation
Episode 18 · 56 min
Some people have dramatic conversion stories, or clear calls into ministry. Kristal Poff's story is quieter, and it has shaped a lot of students.
It started with small yeses. A willingness to show up, ask a friend how they’re doing, or lead a Bible study she didn’t feel ready for. Over time, those yeses added up to a ministry defined by presence, prayer, and people.
In this episode, Crystal shares how her own spiritual transformation became the foundation for helping others grow in faith. From campus ministry in West Virginia to supporting church plants around the country, she’s learned that the most lasting evangelism often looks like friendship, consistency, and simply being there.
An Unexpected Yes
Crystal’s path into ministry wasn’t dramatic. No lightning bolt. No career change. Just an open heart and an invitation to serve. But that first step, helping disciple women at her church in West Virginia, opened the door to a calling that has become central to her life.
As part of the Collegiate Church Network, Kristal has invested in students in several cities, mentored staff and supported church planters. People trust her to tell them the truth and to encourage them. Her résumé matters less than the way she approaches people.
“I never felt like the expert. I just tried to be available, to listen, and to walk with people toward Jesus.”
Evangelism That Feels Like Real Life
For Kristal, evangelism happens naturally when we live close to others and pay attention to what God is doing in their lives. It is part of ordinary life instead of a special event or an assigned task.
She shares about the power of slowing down, being interruptible, and having spiritual conversations that aren’t forced but honest. Whether it’s with students in her church, young women she disciples, or neighbors around her dinner table, Crystal believes transformation happens in the context of relationship.
“We’re not selling something. We’re inviting people into life.”
Shepherding Women on Campus and Beyond
One of Crystal’s passions is helping women embrace their voice and calling. She’s walked with many who feel unsure, under-equipped, or overwhelmed. Her approach? Gentle clarity, patient discipleship, and real encouragement.
She tells women that evangelism takes trust as well as boldness: trust that God will use your story, that the Spirit will give you words and that your presence matters even when you feel small.
“God doesn’t wait for us to feel ready. He invites us to trust Him and go.”
Making Room for God to Move
Crystal also reflects on how easy it is to crowd out the Spirit’s work with busyness, comparison, or fear. Her own life has been shaped by rhythms of slowing down, learning to be present to the people right in front of her, rather than chasing the next thing.
She encourages listeners to make room in their hearts as well as their calendars, for prayer, for questions and for small acts of obedience. That is often where evangelism happens.
“When we make room, God shows up. He always does.”
Final Encouragement
You don’t have to be loud. You don’t have to be polished. You just have to be present. That’s the heart of Crystal’s ministry, and her life.
“Jesus doesn’t need your perfection. He wants your participation.”
Whether you’re discipling a friend, helping start a church, or just wondering if your small yes matters, Crystal’s story will remind you that God is faithful with the seeds we plant.
Resources Mentioned
Scripture Anchors
1 Peter 3:15 - Always be prepared to give an answer for the hope you have
Isaiah 30:15: In quietness and trust is your strength
John 15: Remain in me, and you will bear much fruit
Practices to Try
Ask someone how you can pray for them, and follow up later
Create space in your schedule for spiritual conversations
Reflect on how God has used someone else’s availability in your own life
Practice spiritual hospitality by inviting someone into your home
Keep Going
Start small. Stay faithful. Say yes again.
Guests & resources
Meet the guest
- Kristal Poff
New Life Christian Fellowship